Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Year when Didi gunned for Modi seeking to emerge as face of anti-BJP opposition

Year when Didi gunned for Modi seeking to emerge as face of anti-BJP opposition

Mamata Banerjee and Narendra ModiBy Sirshendu Panth,

Kolkata : Keeping up a strong anti-BJP rhetoric, West Bengal’s indefatigable ‘Didi’ gunned for Prime Minister Narendra Modi through the year, lacing her speeches and social media postings with sarcasm and choice words as her government clashed with the Centre on various issues.

From mythology to ancient Indian history, Trinamool Congress supremo Mamata Banerjee left nothing untouched in letting loose incessant verbal volleys at Modi, while the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) continued to increase its vote-share in various by-polls and local body elections in West Bengal.

As the BJP tried to emerge as a viable alternative to the Trinamool, Banerjee in turn endeavoured to project herself as the most prominent opponent of the Hindutva brigade nationally.

The feisty leader networked with regional leaders opposed to the Sangh Parivar — the ideological parent of the BJP as well as several right-wing outfits — and formulated decisions and actions that could give her brownie points over the central dispensation and its propelling force.

She fired on all cylinders, targeting Modi’s key policies like demonetisation and the Goods and Services Tax (GST) while trying to exploit burning issues like sliding economic growth, rampant intolerance, the beef ban and cow vigilantism.

However, it was her colourful and strident attacks on Modi that grabbed the spotlight.

If she likened Modi to the greatest Sanskrit poet and dramatist Kalidasa, it was not because of the writer’s literary prowess but only a reference to an oft-told story of him “lacking intelligence as a youngster — cutting the branch he was sitting on”.

“All institutions (of the nation) are under attack. This is a dangerous game. The PM is behaving like Kalidasa, trying to cut the branch he is sitting on,” Banerjee remarked.

During another aggressive speech, Banerjee drew a parallel between Modi and demon king Ravana of the Ramayana epic.

“He claims that he has broad chest and shoulders. Even Ravana had broad shoulders. And he also had 10 heads,” she said, alluding to Modi’s drumbeating that he has a “56-inch chest”.

On another occasion, she predicted that “Barda” (elder brother) will have to bow out of office after the 2019 parliamentary polls.

Addressing a public meeting in Bankura district, Banerjee raised the pitch further, dubbing the Modi government “deaf and dumb”. But a separate barb was reserved for the Prime Minister.

“He used to call himself a ‘chaiwala’ (tea seller) before. Now he has become a millionaire ‘Paytm-wala’ (one who endorses e-wallets like Paytm).”

Demonetisation, to her, was Modi’s “shameless flop show” that she dismissed on Twitter as “visionless, missionless and directionless”.

Not in a mood to let go of any democratic mode of protest, she even knocked on the door of then President Pranab Mukherjee, urging him to “save the country from the mess” and sought a “national government” minus Modi. Banerjee was ready to accept another BJP leader at its helm and went to the extent of naming L.K. Advani, Rajnath Singh and Arun Jaitley as being acceptable.

While backing GST, Banerjee took the Modi government to task for rolling out the new regime with “disastrous hurry” on July 1. She called the step “another epic blunder” of the Centre.

The CBI probes into the multi-billion-rupee Saradha Ponzi scam, Rose Valley Ponzi scam and Narada sting footage controversy — in which a number of Trinamool leaders were implicated — were also bones of contention between the Trinamool and the BJP.

While Banerjee accused the central agencies of acting out of “political vendetta” on the BJP’s directions, the saffron party said it was an inquiry ordered by the Supreme Court.

Going ballistic, Banerjee threatened to slap defamation cases worth crores of rupees if the CBI did not proceed impartially.

The political battles between the Trinamool regime and the Centre even stretched to observance of red letter dates like Independence Day and Teachers Day.

When the Union Ministry of Human Resources Development (MHRD) sent a circular to the states recommending a structured format promoting Modi’s pet “Swachh Bharat Mission” during Teachers’ Day celebrations in schools, the Mamata government shot off a counter-circular to schools saying the date needed to be observed with due reverence and solemnity as in “earlier years”.

Ahead of Independence Day, the MHRD had issued a circular specifying “additional activities”. But the state government came up with a directive asking the schools to “stop all preparations” for celebrating the day in the MHRD format.

With the Congress weakening, Banerjee kept herself busy attempting to strengthen ties throughout 2017 with prominent political leaders in the anti-BJP domain, particularly those from the regional parties.

She has been following many of them on Twitter, or exchanging pleasantries through tweets with the likes of ex-Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Akhilesh Yadav, senior Jammu and Kashmir National Conference leaders Farooq Abdullah and Omar Abdullah, BSP chief Mayawati and DMK leader M.K. Stalin. She even met Shiv Sena chief Uddhav Thackeray, a BJP baiter despite being an ally, though her party’s views on religion and secularism were diametrically opposed to those of the Sena.

Though Banerjee has stressed on “collective leadership” to challenge Modi, she gave enough hints at a media conclave last month that she is not averse to taking the lead in bringing together opposition parties on a single platform against the BJP in 2019.

(Sirshendu Panth can be contacted at s.panth@ians.in)

—IANS

Collective leadership against Modi in 2019 polls will do opposition good: Trinamool’s Derek O’Brien

Collective leadership against Modi in 2019 polls will do opposition good: Trinamool’s Derek O’Brien

Derek O'Brien

Derek O’Brien

By Prashant Sood & Sidhartha Dutta,

New Delhi : The opposition should not pitch the next Lok Sabha polls as a presidential-style contest against Prime Minister Narendra Modi, says Trinamool Congress leader Derek O’Brien who feels a “collective leadership” would bring parties together against the BJP in each state.

He also says that Bengal will play a very important role in the collective leadership of opposition parties, an obvious reference to his party supremo Mamata Banerjee.

“In 2019, the opposition has to work out a strategy which will be to play to its strength in all 29 states. I am saying this as student of politics. For example, when we are fighting the election in Bengal, obviously it is going to be Mamata di who is the prime mover there,” O’Brien, Trinamool Congress leader in the Rajya Sabha, told IANS in an interview.

He also said that West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee can play a role in bringing opposition parties together in crucial states such as Uttar Pradesh.

“In Uttar Pradesh, there is Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP), Samajwadi Party (SP) and Congress. Who is the most credible person to make this thing happen? Congress is a player, SP is a player, BSP is a player. Mamata di is the good one to do this job in UP. They will have to listen eventually,” O’Brien said.

He said Mamata Banerjee has won a second term and has credibility of four decades.

“She has got a track record of people’s movement, struggles. They are not some five-six year phenomenon, this is an old track record. Those are the people who will take the important roles but it will be a collective leadership,” he said.

Asked if Mamata Banerjee could be prime ministerial candidate, O’Brien said: “I told you it is collective leadership. Bengal will play a very important role. Don’t ask me about personalities,” he said.

He said Trinamool Congress can play the role of a bridge between the Congress and the Aam Aadmi Party in Delhi and, in the same way, the Congress can play the role of a bridge between the Trinamool Congress and the Left in West Bengal.

Answering another query, the chief national spokesperson of Trinamool Congress said the Prime Ministerial candidate is chosen from the party with largest seats in parliamentary democracy.

“This is not a Presidential election. Why should the Lok Sabha election be pitched as a Presidential election. This is not Trump versus Clinton,” he said.

On the likelihood of the Congress projecting party Vice President Rahul Gandhi as the prime ministerial candidate, O’Brien said: “At this stage, it looks (like)… it’s easier to take on Modi with a strong face in each state.”

He said Rahul Gandhi will be president of his party and Trinamool Congress wishes him well.

Asked if he was suggesting there should not be a single candidate against Modi, O’Brien said he was not a spokesperson for 18 parties which have been coordinating their actions against the government.

He said opposition should play to its strengths in all the 29 states.

“Who says opposition does not have a face? Doesn’t Karnataka stand a better chance if Mr. Siddaramaiah is the face to take on whoever in the BJP?”

He said Rahul Gandhi’s imminent elevation this month was “Congress’ internal decision”.

“What I can tell you from what I have seen, again as a student of politics, is that there has been a lot of momentum after his US townhall style meetings. There has been some momentum in the Gujarat campaign… Obviously, if he keeps this momentum going, it’s good for the opposition. A strong Congress is good for the opposition,” he said.

Asked about leaders like Mamata Banerjee having a certain comfort level with Congress president Sonia Gandhi, O’Brien said: “Please give Rahul Gandhi some time as president of the Congress.”

He said Trinamool Congress will do what it takes to make the opposition stronger to defeat the BJP.

The party’s target, he said, is to win all 42 Lok Sabha seats in West Bengal. “For two reasons people will vote for us — one is development, the other is communal harmony.”

O’Brien’s first political book, “Inside Parliament: Views From the Front Row”, was released last week. It has a chapter “BJP is beatable in 2019”.

The Trinamool Congress national spokesperson also said opposition parties have been coordinating inside and outside parliament and had made a statement by fielding good candidates for the presidential and vice-presidential polls.

Referring to 18 parties’ observing the first anniversary of demonetisation on November 8 as Black Day, O’Brien said: “We came to the conclusion that let us allow every party to interpret that protest in the local language and idiom, in the local situation and then make it a success.”

He said the opposition strategy to oust the BJP government was not a negative strategy. “It is a positive strategy. Strengthen federalism to run; that’s the positive strategy.”

—IANS