Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Comparison between Babari Masjid with Hagia Sofia is illogical

Comparison between Babari Masjid with Hagia Sofia is illogical

Hagia Sophia

Hagia Sophia

By Syed Ali Mujtaba

Turkey has come out with an official clarification to those protesting against its government’s decision to convert Hagia Sofia, the world famous monument into a mosque in Istanbul.

Hagia Sophia was built a Church under Byzantine rulers in 537 AD. It was converted into Great Mosque of Ayasofya in 1453 when Ottomans conquered Turkey. In 1931 Turkish nationalist leader Mustafa Kemal Atatürk first President converted the marvel structure into a secular museum.

In a recent development Turkey’s current President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has passed an order to revert the Hagia Sofia into Great Mosque of Ayasofya. The first prayers in this grand mosque will be held on Friday July 24 2020 after almost 85 years.

The decision of the Turkish government has turned heads worldwide more so in the Christian world that pointed fingers at President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan taking Turkey to the medieval age.

Critics called this move of the Turkish President as clash of civilization between Islam and Christianity. This controversy has echoes is India, with Hindu radicals are holding the tail coat of the Christian protestors. The Hindutva radicals joins the hurt feelings of the Christians in  this clash Civilization as it fits into the political design of anti-Muslim, anti-Islam project that is currently underway as a “Lok Abhiyan” in India.

Some apologists refuse to see it as an internal matter of Turkey and have jumped into the Clash of Civilization debate and equate the development of conversion of Hagia Sofia museum into Ayasofya Mosque in Istanbul with the conversion Babari Mosque‘s into Ram temple in Ayodhya.

There are some who try to read the conversion of Hagia Sofia museam into a mosque by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan as an attempt to replicate “Jai Sri Ram Model” of India to remain in power in Turkey.

Putting an end to the dominant narrative on Hagia Sofia, the Turkish Foreign Minister L Abu Bakr has issued a press note on the subject which is an eye opener to the world and also to the judicial and political elite of India, who colluded to deny Muslims their rightful ownership of their house of worship.

Turkish Foreign Minister L Abu Bakr has claimed that Sultan Muhammad II also known as Muhammad Al- Fateh, after opening the gates of Constantinople (Istanbul), offered the Pastor of Church Hagia Sofia to buy the building as an individual purchaser of the said property.

The Turkish Foreign Minister L Abu Bakr released the sale deed or purchase contract with the photos and copies of documents associated with it. The Turkish government manually reviewed 27 thousands documents and found the original title deed (Tabou) that exists in the name of buyer Abu Al- Fateh also known as Sultan Muhammad II.

The copy of the sale deed document that was executed at that time was released by the Turkish Minister. It stated that the buyer Abu Al- Fateh has bought this property through his own money. The sale deed says that Abu Al- Fateh has purchased this property through its own hard earned money and is pure of any evil or vice source of earnings.  The sale deed mentions that this money is not taken from the State treasury or from common Muslim funding and his private source of income.

The Minister mentions that this sale deed was documented through a purchase and waiver contract, and payment was made through payment bonds. The document clearly proves that Hagia Sofia a private property with the ownership in the name of Abul Al- Fateh, the Minister said.

He claimed that there exists an endowment in the name of Sultan Muhammad II that is related to ‘Aya Sofia.’  The landlord of the property Hagia Sofia created an endowment and willed the building be made a mosque and the people of Islamic faith can use it as house of worship.

The Minister said these documents are in public domain now and anyone can go through these papers before attacking the Turkish government’s move to reconvert museum Hagia Sofia as Great Mosque of Ayasofya.

The Minister however was silent about the role of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk in converting the Great Mosque of Ayasofya in to a museum.  Mustafa Kemal Atatürk and led the foundation of the Turkish Republic in 1923 and he initiated a rigorous reforms that transformed Turkey into a modern, progressive and secular nation-state.

The release of documents by the Turkish government has cleared the dust that had settled over Hagia Sofia.  All those who joined the chorus of Clash of Civilization have to shut their mouths, including those in India.

The disclosures of the Turkish Minister has put mirror on those equating Hagia Sofia with with the Babari Mosque‘s conversion into Ram temple in Ayodhya.  These two are separate matters and cannot be compared but have some food for thought for all.

Babari Masjid was built in 1528 by one Mir Baqi on a land duly purchased by him from his earned money, free from any vice or evil means of earnings. Baqi named the mosque as “Babri Masjid,” the ruler of the day.

The Supreme Court pronounced its judgment in Babari Masjid vs Ram Janambohmi case 2019. The court has admitted that Mir Baqi constructed the Babari mosque in 1528.  He did not do by demolishing any Hindu temple.

The Supreme Court admits that prayers were held in the Babari mosque till 1948.  The court also said that the installation of the idol in the Babari mosque in 1948 was unlawful. The court also called the demolition of the Babari Masjid on 6th December 1992 as illegal.

In spite of all these admissions, the Supreme Court ruled that the disputed property belongs to Hindu claimants because Muslim party has not sufficiently established its claim.

The Apex court of India while giving the disputed site to the Hindu party asked the government to constitute a board that can proceed with the construction of the Ram temple where Babari Masjid stood for nearly 500 years.

However, the court did not give the same instruction to the government to constitute a board for the Muslim party to construct a mosque. It simply asked the government to allocate 5 acres of land elsewhere where Muslims can construct a mosque.

This judgment favoring the majority community though defused the highly charged communal atmosphere of the country but left the Muslim minority in despair but even though many felt is a travesty of justice but accepted the judgment as fait accompli for being born in India.

So there is no comparison between Hagia Sofia and Babari Masjid. A mosque is a house of Allah if that is built with due procedure of the Islamic faith and Babari masjid will be remembered as mosque with black judgment on that has made it a Ram temple.

——

Syed Ali Mujtaba is a journalist based in Chennai. He can be contacted at syedalimujtaba2007@gmail.com

Turkey-Syria talks underway at ‘lower levels’: Erdogan

Turkey-Syria talks underway at ‘lower levels’: Erdogan

 

Recep Tayyip Erdogan

Recep Tayyip Erdogan

Ankara : Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has said that talks were underway at lower levels with Syria, ruling out any contact at higher levels with Damascus.

 

“Talks at lower levels must continue with Syria even if not between leaders,” Erdogan said during a live-broadcast interview with Turkish broadcaster TRT, Xinhua news agency reported on Sunday.

Turkey broke all contacts with the Syrian government at the start of the civil war in 2011 and sought to oust President Bashar al-Assad by offering support to some rebel groups.

During their last meeting in Moscow on January 23, Russian President Vladimir Putin encouraged Erdogan to establish some form of contact with the Syrian leadership, invoking a Turkish-Syrian security pact signed in 1998 that could be reactivated to address the security concerns of the two neighbours.

—IANS

Trump speaks with Erdogan after threatening to ‘devastate’ Turkey’s economy

Trump speaks with Erdogan after threatening to ‘devastate’ Turkey’s economy

 

Donald Trump and Recep Tayyip Erdogan

Donald Trump and Recep Tayyip Erdogan

Washington : US President Donald Trump and his Turkish counterpart Recep Tayyip Erdogan discussed “ongoing cooperation in Syria as American forces begin to withdraw” during a phone call, just a day after Trump threatened to “devastate Turkey economically” if the NATO-allied country attacks Kurdish militia in the region.

 

“The President expressed the desire to work together to address Turkey’s security concerns in northeast Syria while stressing the importance to the US that Turkey does not mistreat the Kurds and other Syrian Democratic Forces with whom we have fought to defeat the IS (Islamic State),” CNN quoted White House press secretary Sarah Sanders as saying on Monday night about the call that took place earlier in the day.

Sanders said that Chairman of the Joint Chiefs Gen. Joseph Dunford will meet his Turkish counterpart on Tuesday “to continue consultations” on Syria.

“Gen. Dunford is scheduled to meet his Turkish counterpart this week on the sidelines of the NATO Military Committee in Chiefs of Defence Session, which will be held on Tuesday and Wednesday at the NATO Headquarters in Brussels, Belgium,” Col. Patrick Ryder, a spokesperson for Dunford told CNN.

On Monday night, Trump confirmed the phone call in a tweet.

“Spoke with President Erdogan of Turkey to advise where we stand on all matters including our last two weeks of success in fighting the remnants of IS, and 20 mile safe zone. Also spoke about economic development between the US and Turkey – great potential to substantially expand,” he wrote.

During the call, Erdogan told Trump that Turkey backs the President’s withdrawal decision and extends all kinds of support to the US, according to Turkish news agency Anadolu.

Anadolu said Erdogan emphatically told Trump that Turkey does not have any problems with the Kurds and that “Turkey aims to fight all terror organisations including IS, PKK (The Kurdistan Workers Party) and its cross-border extensions that are threat to its national security”.

The two leaders agreed on developing bilateral economic relations to a higher level, according to the report, CNN reported.

Monday’s call between Trump and Erdogan comes a day after the US President issued a stark threat toward Turkey, saying that Washington “will devastate Turkey economically if they hit Kurds”.

Turkey views some Kurdish groups in the region as terrorist groups and Kurds make up the majority of US-allied fighters operating in Syria in the civil war against Syrian President Bashar al-Assad’s regime.

Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu responded directly to Trump’s comments on Monday prior to the phone call.

“As for Donald Trump’s threat language, we have repeatedly said that we will not be afraid of any threat… You cannot have any result from threatening Turkey economically. We need to see how we can solve this problem together.”

—IANS

Turkish economy strong enough to overcome pressure: Erdogan

Turkish economy strong enough to overcome pressure: Erdogan

President Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

President Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

Ankara : President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said on Wednesday that Turkey would overcome the economic hardships it is currently facing due to external economic pressure amid a diplomatic row with the United States.

Speaking at the Media Oscars award ceremony held by the Broadcast Journalists Association, Erdogan said: “It is obvious that there are structural economic problems that need to be resolved. We are already aware of them and working on the solution. Our infrastructure is strong enough to overcome these problems.”

The row between Turkey and the U.S. escalated when U.S. President Donald Trump decided to impose sanctions on Turkish Ministers Süleyman Soylu and Abdülhamit Gül on August 1 and also increase tariffs on imported steel from Turkey by 50 percent and aluminum by 20 percent, while threatening more sanctions over the detention of terror-linked Evangelical Pastor Andrew Brunson.

The pastor is under house arrest in Turkey on charges of links to the Gülenist Terror Group (FETÖ) and the PKK, a U.S.-designated armed terrorist organization. In retaliation, Turkey increased tariffs on certain U.S. goods by up to 100 percent and higher.

The Turkish president said that the structural problems alone could not be enough reason for the current issues in the country’s economy, stating: “Some people do not shy away from admitting that they are trying to corner Turkey.”

Erdogan assured that necessary measures had been taken and allies are also supporting Turkey financially, reiterating that Ankara will not bow to Washington’s threats.

Turkey garnered extensive support from European partners such as France and Germany, as well as Russia, China, Kuwait and Qatar who raised their voices to highlight the significance of the Turkish economy, amid attacks from the threatening economic showdown initiated by Trump.

—SM/UNA-OIC

Turkey to boycott US-made electronic products: Erdogan

Turkey to boycott US-made electronic products: Erdogan

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan

Ankara : Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Tuesday announced that his country will boycott American electronic products.

The announcement came in his address to a symposium organized by the Foundation for Political, Economic and Social Research (SETA) on the 17th foundation anniversary of the ruling Justice and Development (AK) Party.

“We will boycott American electronic products,” Erdogan said, adding that Turkey would produce a better version of every product previously bought with foreign currencies and export them.

“They do not hesitate to use the economy as a weapon against us, as they [also] tried in the diplomatic or military field, and efforts to sow social and political instability,” he added.

Turkey and the United States are currently experiencing rocky relations following Washington’s imposition of sanctions on Interior Minister Suleyman Soylu and Justice Minister Abdulhamit Gul for not releasing US Pastor Andrew Brunson, who faces terrorism charges in Turkey.

President Donald Trump on Friday ramped up his attack on Turkey by doubling US tariffs on Turkish aluminum and steel imports to 20 percent and 50 percent, respectively.

—AB/UNA-OIC